volume: 46, issue: 2
Ground-based forest operations can produce an intense level of soil disturbance and hamper the growth of seedlings. However, previous studies on the topic of seedling growth performance on the skid trail network showed high variability and non-uniform responses. Therefore, a multivariate meta-analysis was applied to investigate the effects of soil disturbance after ground-based forest operations on the aboveground and belowground growth of seedlings. We further assessed the effects of the following moderators: type of regeneration, type of stand, number of years since the forest operations, mass of the machine used, number of machine passes in the investigated skid trails, and the increased soil compaction in the skid trails. The results supported our hypothesis that ground-based forest operations had a greater effect on the growth of broadleaf species and natural regeneration. This was, however, mostly true for belowground growth, that was typically more affected than aboveground growth. We discovered that there is a recovery in seedling biomass and lenght following harvesting, but this is a long process that requires about ten to twenty years to begin. We found that the number of machine passes and the machine mass did not directly correspond to a higher level of impact, indicating that the actual disturbance drivers are more complicated interactions that occur among the machine, the way in which forest operations are carried out, and the soil properties. It was finally demonstrated that soil compaction was the primary cause of disturbance to seedling growth, primarily affecting belowground biomass and lenght. In particular, we identified a minimum threshold of a 30% increase in soil bulk density to observe statistically significant negative effects on seedling belowground growth. Soil compaction proved to be the main factor that can jeopardize the development of forest regeneration in the skid trails. This suggests that the same best management practices that are used to reduce soil compaction caused by machinery should also be used to reduce the detrimental effects of ground-based forest operations on seedling development. As future research directions, long-term studies are recommended to assess the recovery process dynamics. Moreover, more research on broadleaf, natural regeneration, and Cut-to-Length machinery is strongly suggested.
volume: issue, issue:
Forest operations, particularly ground-based skidding, are known to cause soil disturbances, yet their long-term impact on soil biological communities remains understudied. The goal of this study was to assess the effects of thinning and skidding on Mesostigmata mite communities in Polish beech forests, analyzing soil disturbance in skid trails, undisturbed harvested areas, and unharvested control sites. This study is especially needed in Polish beech forests, considering that recently both the shift towards continuous cover forestry and the increasing demand for beech timber have fostered the shortening of the re-entry intervals between two consecutive logging operations in the same forest management unit. Further to the above, the aim of this study was to leverage a well-recognized indicator of soil health, i.e. mite biodiversity, to check both the short-term consequences of ground-based forest operations and the related recovery times after harvesting. A total of 670 individual mites from 49 taxa were identified, with significant reductions in abundance and diversity in the disturbed soil. Mite abundance in recently established skid trails was approximately 80% lower than in unharvested control sites, while species richness and diversity were reduced fivefold. Even five years after logging, mite abundance and diversity remained three times lower than in unharvested stands, indicating prolonged recovery. Unexpectedly, uncompacted soil within harvested blocks also showed a 50–75% decrease in mite diversity, suggesting that thinning alone can significantly affect soil mites. Statistical analyses revealed strong correlations between mite abundance and soil penetration resistance and organic matter content, emphasizing the role of both compaction and organic matter depletion in shaping soil biodiversity. Given that the current re-entry interval is insufficient for biological recovery, forest management should consider increasing the re-entry interval, implementing further soil protection measures to skid trails, and assessing alternative extraction methods, e.g. forwarding. These findings highlight how integrating soil biological indicators into forestry operations planning can lead to lowered impacts on soil and soil biota.
volume: 48, issue: 1
Forest operations, particularly ground-based skidding, are known to cause soil disturbances, yet their long-term impact on soil biological communities remains understudied. The goal of this study was to assess the effects of thinning and skidding on Mesostigmata mite communities in Polish beech forests, analyzing soil disturbance in skid trails, undisturbed harvested areas, and unharvested control sites. This study is especially needed in Polish beech forests, considering that recently both the shift towards continuous cover forestry and the increasing demand for beech timber have fostered the shortening of the re-entry intervals between two consecutive logging operations in the same forest management unit. Further to the above, the aim of this study was to leverage a well-recognized indicator of soil health, i.e. mite biodiversity, to check both the short-term consequences of ground-based forest operations and the related recovery times after harvesting. A total of 670 individual mites from 49 taxa were identified, with significant reductions in abundance and diversity in the disturbed soil. Mite abundance in recently established skid trails was approximately 80% lower than in unharvested control sites, while species richness and diversity were reduced fivefold. Even five years after logging, mite abundance and diversity remained three times lower than in unharvested stands, indicating prolonged recovery. Unexpectedly, uncompacted soil within harvested blocks also showed a 50–75% decrease in mite diversity, suggesting that thinning alone can significantly affect soil mites. Statistical analyses revealed strong correlations between mite abundance and soil penetration resistance and organic matter content, emphasizing the role of both compaction and organic matter depletion in shaping soil biodiversity. Given that the current re-entry interval is insufficient for biological recovery, forest management should consider increasing the re-entry interval, implementing further soil protection measures to skid trails, and assessing alternative extraction methods, e.g. forwarding. These findings highlight how integrating soil biological indicators into forestry operations planning can lead to lowered impacts on soil and soil biota.